“Dismissed”: Supreme Court Won’t Share Details Of Judges’ Appointment Meet

“Dismissed”: Supreme Court Won’t Share Details Of Judges’ Appointment Meet

Whatever is discussed (in collegium meetings), shall not be in the public domain, said the Supreme Court.

New Delhi:

The Supreme Court today dismissed a request for details of a meeting of its top panel on the appointment of judges, declaring that these discussions cannot be revealed to the public.

“Whatever is discussed (in collegium meetings) shall not be in the public domain. Only the final decision needs to be uploaded,” the Supreme Court said.

A petition had sought details of a Collegium meeting on December 12, 2018, on the appointment of two judges, which were never made public. The petitioner, activist Anjali Bhardwaj, had sought the details under the Right To Information Act but it was denied, and she had challenged the decision.

The judges noted that the petitioner had “relied on articles” based on interviews by one of the judges present in that meeting.

“We do not want to comment on the same. The subsequent resolution was very clear. There is no substance in the (petition), it deserves to be dismissed,” said the Supreme Court.

In the meeting in question, then Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi and four senior-most judges – Justices Madan B Lokur, AK Sikri, SA Bobde and NV Ramana – took some decisions on appointment of judges. The details of the meeting were not uploaded on the Supreme Court website.

The decisions were later overturned.

Justice Lokur had in January 2019 expressed disappointment that the resolution in that meeting was not uploaded.

Source link